Best Independent Elementary Schools in St. Louis: What to Look For
Choosing the right elementary school is one of the most important decisions a parent can make. In a city like St. Louis—rich with educational options—families are often drawn to the benefits of independent schools: smaller class sizes, mission-driven teaching, and communities that truly know each child.
But what makes an independent elementary school stand out? And how do you know if it’s the right fit for your family?
Whether you’re just starting your school search or narrowing down your options, here are the key qualities to look for in the best independent elementary schools in the St. Louis area.
🔍 1. A Strong Educational Philosophy That Goes Beyond Test Scores
The best schools don’t just teach to the test—they teach to the child. Look for a school that has a clearly defined philosophy and approach to learning. Whether it’s project-based, inquiry-driven, or something else, great schools can tell you why they do what they do—and how it benefits your child long-term.
➡️ At Rohan Woods School, for example, we use the Project Approach to immerse students in real-world topics that integrate math, literacy, science, and leadership development in meaningful ways.
🧑🏫 2. Engaged, Accessible Teachers Who Know Each Child
In independent schools, teachers aren’t just instructors—they’re mentors and guides. You should feel that your child will be known by their teachers, not just for their academic ability, but for their personality, strengths, and growth areas.
Ask on your tour:
- How is instruction personalized and how often do teachers give individualized feedback?
- How do they support advanced learners or students who need extra attention?
📚 3. Integrated, Hands-On Learning
The best independent schools don’t rely solely on textbooks—they bring learning to life. From field trips and classroom experiments to service projects and interdisciplinary units, look for programs that challenge students to think critically and apply their knowledge.
Ask:
- What does a typical day in 3rd or 5th grade look like?
- Do students work on collaborative projects?
- Are there leadership or public speaking opportunities
🌍 4. A Nurturing School Culture That Builds Character
Academic success is important—but so is helping your child become a confident, respectful, and responsible person. Independent schools often emphasize values-based education, encouraging students to take ownership of their behavior and contribute to their community.
Look for evidence of:
- Leadership development
- Conflict resolution skills
- Community-building traditions
- Peer collaboration and kindness
🏫 5. Strong Parent Communication and Community Feel
A great school feels like an extension of your family—not a place where you drop off and disappear. Independent schools often build close-knit communities where parents are involved, teachers are responsive, and school leadership is approachable.
Ask:
- How does the school communicate with parents?
- Are there opportunities for parent involvement?
- How does the school handle transitions and tough moments (like drop-off, social challenges, or academic hurdles)?
📍 6. Convenient Location and Sustainable Class Sizes
While the best fit should always be your top priority, proximity matters—especially for families balancing work and sibling logistics. Many families in St. Louis, West County, and St. Charles are looking for schools that are accessible yet provide strong academics, small class size, personalized instruction, and leadership development.
🎓 Finding the Right Fit for Your Family
There’s no one-size-fits-all answer to “What’s the best school?” The best independent elementary school for your child is one that aligns with your family’s values, meets your child where they are, and prepares them for the world ahead—not just the next test.
If you’re beginning your search in the St. Louis area, we’d love to invite you to explore Rohan Woods School—a small, nurturing, academically rich independent school serving children age 2 through Grade 6. We’re proud to offer an educational experience that combines academic depth, personalized learning, and leadership development in every grade.
📅 Schedule a tour today or email mcomesana@rohanwoods.org. We’re here to help you find the right fit—whether it’s here or somewhere else.
